ETFs vs Index Funds: Which is Right for NZ Investors?

When building a diversified investment portfolio, you'll likely encounter two popular options: Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) and Index Funds. While they share many similarities, understanding their differences can help you make better investment decisions.

What Are Index Funds?

Index funds are investment funds that track a specific market index, such as the S&P 500 or NZX 50. They aim to match the performance of their benchmark index rather than trying to beat it.

Key Characteristics

• Passive management: Lower costs due to minimal trading
• Diversification: Instant exposure to many companies
• Transparency: Holdings mirror the index
• Lower minimums: Many allow small investments

What Are ETFs?

ETFs are similar to index funds but trade on stock exchanges like regular shares. You can buy and sell ETFs throughout the trading day at market prices.

Key Characteristics

• Real-time trading: Buy/sell anytime markets are open
• Price flexibility: Market price may differ from NAV
• Brokerage fees: Each trade incurs a transaction cost
• More variety: Cover indexes, commodities, sectors

Head-to-Head Comparison

| Feature | Index Funds | ETFs | |---------|-------------|------| | Trading | End of day | Real-time | | Minimum investment | Often $500+ | Price of one share | | Transaction costs | None (usually) | Brokerage per trade | | Expense ratios | Low | Low to very low | | Tax efficiency | Good | Often better | | Flexibility | Less | More |

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Index Funds If:

• You invest regularly (no brokerage fees)
• You want simplicity (set and forget)
• Your platform doesn't charge fund fees
• You're using a PIE fund for tax advantages

Choose ETFs If:

• You want real-time pricing
• You make fewer, larger investments
• You want access to specific sectors/markets
• You're comfortable with stock trading

NZ-Specific Considerations

PIE Funds

Many NZ index funds are structured as Portfolio Investment Entities (PIEs), which offer tax benefits:

• Maximum tax rate of 28%
• Beneficial for higher income earners
• Tax paid at your Prescribed Investor Rate (PIR)

Popular NZ Options

Index Funds (PIE):

• Simplicity NZ Shares
• Kernel NZ 20
• Smartshares NZ Top 50

ETFs:

• Smartshares US 500 ETF
• Smartshares Total World ETF
• Kernel Global 100 ETF

Cost Comparison Example

Let's compare a $10,000 investment:

Monthly $500 Contributions (Index Fund wins)

| | Index Fund | ETF | |---|------------|-----| | Annual fee (0.3%) | $30 | $30 | | Brokerage (12 trades) | $0 | $60 | | Total annual cost | $30 | $90 |

One-time $10,000 Investment (ETF may win)

| | Index Fund | ETF | |---|------------|-----| | Annual fee | 0.30% | 0.20% | | Initial brokerage | $0 | $5 | | Year 1 cost | $30 | $25 |

Building a Portfolio

Many investors use a combination of both:

1. Core holdings: Low-cost index funds or ETFs tracking broad markets
2. Satellite positions: ETFs for specific sectors or themes
3. Regular contributions: Index funds to avoid brokerage fees

Sample Portfolio

• 40% - NZ Shares Index Fund
• 40% - Global Shares Index Fund
• 20% - Emerging Markets ETF

Getting Started

Ready to invest? Here are your next steps:

1. Compare platforms - Use our platform comparison
2. Understand fees - Check our fee calculator
3. Start small - You don't need much to begin
4. Stay consistent - Regular contributions beat timing the market

The Bottom Line

Both index funds and ETFs are excellent tools for building wealth. The "best" choice depends on:

• How often you invest
• Your investment amount
• Platform fees
• Your preference for control

For most NZ investors making regular contributions, PIE index funds often edge out due to tax efficiency and no brokerage fees. For lump-sum investors or those wanting specific market exposure, ETFs offer more flexibility.

---

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice. Consider your personal circumstances and seek professional advice before investing.